In the NJLA conference talk entitled “How to Talk to Parents About YA Literature,” Jennifer Hubert gave these three main points many parents ask:
1. Why is my teen reading “junk”? Why aren’t they reading the classics??
2. Why is my teen reading the same book over and over, or stuck on a series?
3. Why is my teen obsessed with horror, or books about drugs, sex and murder?
Let’s start with the first question: Why is my teen reading “junk”? Why aren’t they reading the classics? Jennifer Hubert made this point: Teens will be exposed to the classics in high school and college. Leisure reading should be books they choose themselves.
And let’s face it, for many teens, reading classic books inside or outside school is about as much fun as sledding down a mud-covered hill. A person can’t very well sled down a muddy hill; they would get stuck. And for some teens forced to read classic books, that is exactly how they feel. Stuck.
Hubert goes on to say that parents should not be elitists because reading taste varies. “Many “classics” started out as pulp serials, including stuff by Dickens and Alcott. Shakespeare was considered low-brow in his day!”
Just because society does not consider YA books as classics, does not mean they cannot teach just as much to young adults. Many look at it this way: “The THAT of teenagers reading is more important than the WHAT.”–Hippie.
“Developmental needs trump intellectual ones.” It is important for young adults to develop reading skills, even if those reading skills do not come from “the classics.” 71 percent of eighth graders and 65 percent of twelfth graders read below grade average.
That’s because young adults are becoming less willing to read on their own and, consequently, are unable to develop the reading skills they need later in life. Therefore, we need to ask ourselves if the content of what we have our students and teens read is more important than the fact that they are reading at all. “Education is not the filling of a pail, but the lighting of a flame.” –Yeates.
The second question Hubert asks is: Why is my teen reading the same book over and over, or stuck on a series? Hubert then responds: Familiarity is comforting during the changes of adolescence. Reluctant readers feel a sense of accomplishment after completing a series.
It is important to get reluctant readers and all readers alike excited about what they are reading. If a reluctant reader finishes an “easy” series, they feel a sense of accomplishment. Therefore, when the reader comes across a more difficult book or series of books later on, they will feel more confident to read that book or series because now they know they can.
Hubert had this to say: Apply the “Goldilocks” principle: teens choose books that are “too easy” when they need a break, “just right” when they really need to understand a topic, “too hard” when they want to challenge themselves, or are REALLY interested in a topic.
Just because teens are reading things that are considered too easy for them, it should be celebrated to know that 1. They are reading at all and 2. They CAN read more difficult material. It comes down to the fact that if a person wants to read better, they need to read as much as they can. This applies with most everything. If you want to write, sing, dance, and do math better, you must do it as much as you can. If all a young adult knows is classics and they don’t like classics, that young adult isn’t going to want to read anymore because they have not had any positive experiences with reading.
The third and final question Hubert asked was: Why is my teen obsessed with horror, or books about drugs, sex, or murder? Hubert makes this point: Once they are twelve, they know what they can handle. Developmentally, they are interested in life and death issues, and it is better to get it from a YA novel, which is thoughtful and well-meaning, than from an R-rated movie.
Hubert goes on to say: Reading horror is a way for teens to subconsciously deal with some of life’s deepest fears, which are often far worse than vampires and werewolves.
Parents need not worry about teens reading YA literature because those who write it know who they are writing for and there is almost always a good thought-provoking message in the YA book. In the end, it should not matter how much a teen reads, but how much they want to read.
Works Cited
Gibbons, Louel C, Dail, Jennifer S, Stallworth, B Joyce. Young Adult Literature in the English Curriculum Today: Classroom Teachers Speak Out. Arts Publications. CBS Interactive Inc. 2009
Hubert, Jennifer. How to Talk to Parents About YA Literature. NJLA Conference. 2009